• Skip to main content
  • Skip to after header navigation
  • Skip to site footer

A Quiet Simple Life

Sallie Schaaf Borrink

  • Home
  • Start Here
  • Subscribe
  • Categories
    • Christian Faith
    • Comfort Food Recipes
    • Gracious Christian Parenting
      • Gifted/2e Parenting For Christians
    • Homemaking
      • Free Homemaking Printables
      • The Prudent & Prepared Homemaker
    • Homeschooling
      • Relaxed Homeschooling
      • Homeschooling a Creative Child
      • Homeschool Mom Encouragement
      • Homeschool Planning
      • Gifted/2e Homeschooling
    • The Library
    • Our Cozy Family Life
    • Simple Living
    • Unit Studies & Resources
      • Unit Studies
      • Unit Study Printables & Worksheets
      • Unit Study Books
      • Unit Study Activities
  • The Shop
    • Explore The Shop By Category
      • All Products For Women
      • All Products For Children
      • Clip Art & Digital Papers
      • A Quiet Simple Life Series
      • Poetry
      • Editable Homeschool Planners
      • A Full Year Shopping Pass
    • Cart
    • Digital Products Terms of Use
    • Your Account Details
      • View Your Orders
      • Go To Your Downloads
      • My Account
    • Lost Password Help
  • More
    • Tags
    • Donate
    • Recommendations
  • Go To: SRA
You are here: Home / Homeschooling / Should Elementary Students Formally Study Mathematics?




Post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure statement.

Should Elementary Students Formally Study Mathematics?

September 18, 2013 by Sallie Borrink
8 Comments
8         
8
Shares

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In a 2010 article from Psychology Today, Peter Gray, Ph.D., makes the case that math should not be taught until middle school. He shares a fascinating study from 1929 that has largely disappeared from the nation’s collective radar. But the findings are stunning regarding whether or not elementary students should study math.

In When Less Is More: The Case for Teaching Less Math in School he writes:




As part of the plan, he asked the teachers of the earlier grades to devote some of the time that they would normally spend on arithmetic to the new third R–recitation. By “recitation” he meant, “speaking the English language.” He did “not mean giving back, verbatim, the words of the teacher or the textbook.” The children would be asked to talk about topics that interested them–experiences they had had, movies they had seen, or anything that would lead to genuine, lively communication and discussion. This, he thought, would improve their abilities to reason and communicate logically. He also asked the teachers to give their pupils some practice in measuring and counting things, to assure that they would have some practical experience with numbers.

and

The results were remarkable. At the beginning of their sixth grade year, the children in the experimental classes, who had not been taught any arithmetic, performed much better than those in the traditional classes on story problems that could be solved by common sense and a general understanding of numbers and measurement. Of course, at the beginning of sixth grade, those in the experimental classes performed worse on the standard school arithmetic tests, where the problems were set up in the usual school manner and could be solved simply by applying the rote-learned algorithms. But by the end of sixth grade those in the experimental classes had completely caught up on this and were still way ahead of the others on story problems.

In sum, Benezet showed that kids who received just one year of arithmetic, in sixth grade, performed at least as well on standard calculations and much better on story problems than kids who had received several years of arithmetic training. This was all the more remarkable because of the fact that those who received just one year of training were from the poorest neighborhoods–the neighborhoods that had previously produced the poorest test results.

I found this article especially fascinating as I have an almost seven year old daughter who already dislikes math. By math I mean formal math. She has no problem making elaborate constructions with Tinker Toys or figuring out how to evenly divide the cookies. She will decide to measure things on her own. She will clean your clock in Uno. She effectively uses practical math when it makes sense in her world. But like many right brained children, formal math (especially memorization) is not her cup of tea.

I have mostly backed off from math up until this point. We do bits of things, but not a lot. This year I was going to try doing more math (since I’m feeling guilty), but I’m already seeing this is not going to be the year either. I bought the first book of Life of Fred to use this year after reading so many glowing reviews.

She hated it. (Anyone need to buy a copy?) She said she would much rather do the worksheets we were doing last year.




I continue to feel the unschooler in me begging to be given free reign. Somehow I can’t get past my personal hangup that it is just irresponsible to home educate that way even though I know that isn’t true. I observe many unschoolers doing spectacular things and admire how they educate their children. I’m just not able to personally make that final leap (yet). But as I work that out for myself, one thing is certain.

I’ve slowly come to the conclusion that much of what children are asked to do in the elementary years is busy work (often developmentally inappropriate) designed to keep them occupied until they are far enough along the conveyor belt to really begin their formal learning.

Edited: This article is referred to below in the comments: Formal Arithmetic at Age Ten, Hurried or Delayed?

Is elementary math busy work

 





8         
8
Shares
Category: Homeschooling | Homeschooling Elementary School | Relaxed Homeschooling | Right Brained LearnersTag: Dyscalculia | Grades 3-5 | Grades K-2

More Inspiration For You

Stanford Achievement Test For Homeschoolers

Year Round Relaxed Homeschooling and Living By The Seasons

Our Homeschool Learning Room For Fourth Grade

Free Woodworking Fun At Home Depot

Previous Post:An Interview With Monica Wellington
Next Post:Homeschooling, Homework, and Excessive Expectations On Children Today

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Cindy

    September 18, 2013 at 6:11 pm

    I agree that so much of early math is busy work that isn’t developmentally appropriate. We don’t unschool, but I plan activities that are hands-on and/or stimulating – all while being developmentally appropriate. He loves math because most of it seems like game time or plain old fun to him! :o)

    Reply
  2. Crystal

    September 19, 2013 at 9:14 am

    I love this! My daughter (7) does not like math either! I also lean more toward unschooling however we are not there yet? I do not know if I ever will be there but we do have a very laid back style,I find myself sometimes falling into the busy work mode which makes me feel lazy 🙁 Great article!

    Reply
  3. Brandy @ Afterthoughts

    September 19, 2013 at 12:08 pm

    This is so interesting! It actually reminds me a lot of the Bluedorns (who are definitely not unschoolers), who suggest waiting until 10 to introduce mathematics. Their suggestions are based on an understanding of the maturation of the brain. I’ve read the paper their opinion is (mostly) based upon, and it basically says that the part of the brain that is responsible for math isn’t fully myelinated until age 10 in the average child. That struck me when I first read it because I remember thinking that I was “bad at math” as a young child. I could do what my teachers asked me to do, but I knew I didn’t really understand it. Then around age 10 (fourth grade), it all clicked, and I adored math from then on. I even took math on purpose in college. 🙂

    I personally don’t do “no” math (which is technically illegal in CA anyhow), but I only do what the child is capable of, which means that my third grader is just now doing “first grade” math, and my 11yo, though on “grade level” now, was a complete year “behind” at one point. I really think math is so much more tied to brain development than we tend to think, and there is so much shame involved in being “behind”–to the point where we are probably labeling children with immature brains as having learning disabilities!

    Reply
  4. J. Rose Allister

    September 20, 2013 at 1:21 pm

    Math is still very much a work in progress for us, and it was this study (among other things) that helped me relax about my 10-year-old’s current skill set. My daughter most definitely learns at her own pace and in her own way, and math is a prime example. Two years in a charter program showed me just why no amount of drilling, workbooks, math blocks, or even games would give her much more than a disdain for math. Now, a year after withdrawing, she’s finally doing what I feared she never would–seeking out opportunities to learn sums and money. I wish now we hadn’t gone through all that stress.

    Reply
  5. Julie

    December 26, 2013 at 10:20 am

    Sallie, I could’ve written this post. Wow. My daughter, also 7, also dislikes math and I struggle with myself over whether or not to push the issue or let it go. She also dislikes Life of Fred, although her right-brained brothers both like it.
    I’ve mostly let it go. She will do things in bursts, like teaching herself to count to 100, then to 1000, by focusing on it exclusively until she masters it. But give her an addition equation, or goodness help me, pull out the dreaded workbook, and she is outta here.
    Ironically, I found your post while researching a post I’m writing about hands-on math.
    Off to follow you on the various social networks now. Glad to find your blog. 🙂

    Reply
  6. Kristi

    January 27, 2016 at 2:24 pm

    Love this. My almost 7yo (girl) loves math and does it for fun, but my 9 yo (boy) hates it unless it’s for a purpose — Yahtzee, or figuring out his batting average. We have much better school days with less tears and frustration since I gave up on doing daily math. (We’ve also switched to Beast Academy, which is much more fun than regular math curricula. Not like he loves it, though, since it’s still math.)

    Reply
  7. Esther

    March 12, 2016 at 9:48 pm

    Really interesting info, Sallie. My daughter (7) also dislikes math. Well, not all math. She really gets anything related to geometry, patterns, fractions, etc. But we are struggling with the basic math facts. I’m trying to decide what to do next year because what we’ve done this year has definitely not been going great.

    Reply
    • Sallie

      March 15, 2016 at 8:05 pm

      Hi Esther!

      What kind of learner is your daughter? I ask because some kinds of learners do not memorize well, especially math facts.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Thank you for your comment. I read and appreciate each one even if I am unable to respond.

Sidebar

I’m Sallie, Christian wife, mother, homeschooler, and homebody. Do you desire to create a quiet simple life for your family? If so, I invite you to explore my helpful content about the faith-filled and home-centered life. Please start here. Welcome! ♥ 

Categories

Find It Here

My Other Website: Sallie’s Rebuilding America

Popular Right Now

  • The Ultimate List of AIP Comfort Food RecipesThe Ultimate List of AIP Comfort Food Recipes
  • Why I Reject MinimalismWhy I Reject Minimalism
  • The Ginghams Paper Dolls (Free!)The Ginghams Paper Dolls (Free!)
  • How To Grow Planters Full Of PansiesHow To Grow Planters Full Of Pansies
  • 100 Field Trip Ideas for Homeschoolers {Free Printable}100 Field Trip Ideas for Homeschoolers {Free Printable}
  • Why I Homeschool In The Afternoon and Not The MorningWhy I Homeschool In The Afternoon and Not The Morning
  • Happy Birthday To Me!Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Cozy Blogs I'm ReadingCozy Blogs I’m Reading
  • Parenting & Enjoying Your High Need BabyParenting & Enjoying Your High Need Baby
  • How To Talk With Your Daughter About PubertyHow To Talk With Your Daughter About Puberty
  • Decluttering 1,000 ThingsDecluttering 1,000 Things
  • He Drew Me Aside - "I Needed the Quiet" by Alice Hansche MortensonHe Drew Me Aside – “I Needed the Quiet” by Alice Hansche Mortenson
Receive new post notifications from A Quiet Simple Life

Powered by follow.it

Popular Today In The Shop

  • Rhyming Words ActivityRhyming Words Activity
  • Picnic Printable Activity PackPicnic Printable Activity Pack
  • Beach Fun Memory Game PrintableBeach Fun Memory Game Printable
  • Inauguration Day 2021 Printables Activity PackInauguration Day 2021 Printables Activity Pack
  • A Quiet Simple Life Planner & Guidebook (January 2022 - December 2023)A Quiet Simple Life Planner & Guidebook (January 2022 – December 2023)
  • Shapes and Colors Bingo Game Printable Cards 5x5Shapes and Colors Bingo Game Printable Cards 5×5
  • Trees Fun Facts CardsTrees Fun Facts Cards
  • Women's History Month Fun Facts CardsWomen’s History Month Fun Facts Cards
  • Flowers and Plants Fun Fact CardsFlowers and Plants Fun Fact Cards
  • Apple Writing Prompts and PapersApple Writing Prompts and Papers

Join The Conversation

  • Mrs. White on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Pam on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Cheryl on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Lauren on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Amanda on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Marilyn on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Sue Elvis on Happy Birthday To Me!
  • Peggy on Late Winter Days at Home
  • Marilyn on Late Winter Days at Home
  • MERRILYN 9 MERRI0 on Late Winter Days at Home
  • Etti on Breaking Our Bonds: Wokeness Will Destroy National Panhellenic Conference Sororities
  • Mrs. White on A Little Update

Blogging Is Better With Blinkies!

My Blogroll

  • Adventures In Keeping House
  • The Blessed Hearth
  • The Bluebirds Are Nesting On The Farm
  • By Sun and Candlelight 
  • Coffee Tea Books and Me
  • Creekside Cottage
  • Elefantz
  • Exquisitely Unremarkable
  • Generations Before Us
  • Heavenstretch
  • Homemakers Thoughts
  • Hope and Thrift 
  • A Housewife Writes
  • Jane Austen's World
  • The Legacy of Home
  • Like Mother, Like Daughter
  • Love My Life
  • Mama's Learning Corner
  • Mountain Housewife
  • The 1940s Experiment
  • North Ridge Farm
  • Rural Revolution
  • Something From Almost Nothing
  • Strangers and Pilgrims on Earth
  • Stories of an Unschooling Family
  • Sugar Pie Cottage
  • Thinking About Home
  • Thrive On One Income
  • Upon Hope
  • Vox Popoli
  • A Working Pantry 

Lifetime Visits

17,543,827

Archives

Contact Me • Privacy Policy • Disclaimers & Affiliates

Copyright © 2023 · A Quiet Simple Life · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme

Scroll Up