• Skip to main content
  • Skip to after header navigation
  • Skip to site footer

A Quiet Simple Life

  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Categories
        • Books
        • Comfort Food Recipes
        • Free Printables
        • Gifted & 2e
        • Gracious Christian Parenting
        • Homeschool Unit Studies
        • Homeschooling
        • Our Family Stories
        • Simple Living
        • Tags
  • Premium Content
    • Purchase Premium Access
    • Premium Member Log-in
  • Forum (New!)
  • My Printables Shop
    • Explore The Shop
    • Your Cart
    • Your Account Details
      • View Your Orders
      • Go To Your Downloads
      • My Account
    • Lost Password Help
    • Digital Products Terms of Use
  • Search

Welcome & Miscellaneous

See the sidebar for all categories

Start Here

Subscribe

Donate

Tags

Sallie’s Rebuilding America – My News Analysis Website

My Recommendations

The Shop

Explore The Shop

The Lifetime Shopping Pass

Your Cart

Digital Products Terms of Use

Your Account

View Your Orders

Go To Your Downloads

Lost Password Help

Cozy & Simple Living

Simple Living

Homemaking

Our Cozy Family Life

The Prudent & Prepared Homemaker

Free Homemaking Printables

Holidays & Traditions

Comfort Food Recipes

Health

Home Education & Parenting

Home Education

Discipleship Homeschooling

Gracious Christian Parenting

Gifted/2e Parenting for Christians

Homeschooling a Creative Child

Homeschool Mom Encouragement

Homeschool Planning

Gifted/2e Homeschooling

Unit Studies & Themes

Unit Studies & Resources

Unit Studies

Unit Study Activities

Poetry

Christian Faith

Christian Faith

Prayer

Marriage

Bible Readings & Christian Devotionals

Morning Hope

Eventide Blessing

Streams in the Desert

You are here: Home / Simple Living / Just Say “No” to Cookie Cutter Christian Living



Archives

Just Say “No” to Cookie Cutter Christian Living

Sunday, March 5, 2006 (Updated: Wednesday, February 25, 2026)
17 Comments

Post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure statement.

Amy of Amy’s Humble Musings recently posted “A bath for baby.” The post started with this:

The answer to, “How do you do it all?” is simple. Nobody does it all. If you bake your own bread and mill your own wheat, then you probably don’t polish your silverware. If you polish your silverware, you probably don’t parse Latin verbs with your kids. If you do Latin with your kids, you probably don’t have a garden. If you have a garden and do all of the above, you probably don’t take a shower. And I’ll bet your garden has weeds.




To this I say a hearty Amen! And why? Because it is true that no one can do it all. I’ve written before in Simplifying Choices that although I think canning is very cool, I don’t can. I also don’t sew. I’ve needed to do other things that were more important. Life is about trade-offs and we all make them everyday.

As I thought about Amy’s post, I reflected on how vastly different our lives are. We discovered last year that we have the exact same wedding anniversary (including the year). However, our lives have taken vastly different directions over the past nine years. Some differences are simple like she lives in Florida and I live in Michigan. Can you say different weather? But there are more profound differences. She and her husband have five children. We have one that is 1/4 of the way here as I write this! Her husband is a rocket scientist and travels a lot. My husband is a graphic designer and is home 24/7. She gardens and I read gardening catalogs. I work part-time for pay in our home-based business and (to my knowledge) Amy does not work for pay. I’m sure if I knew Amy more, I could share more differences. But I think you get my point that we have completely different lives.

However, we are both seeking to follow Christ. There is no doubt when I read her blog that she wants to be found a faithful servant of Christ. And I hope that those who read my blog would also discern the same thing about me. But that seeking has led to such different lives. That is why the “cookie cutter” mentality regarding Christian living drives me crazy! Within the parameters of Biblical Christian living, there is such a wide variety of God honoring lives.

I think in a desire to “map out” the perfect blueprint for Christian living, many people forget that God creates individuals with unique temperaments, spiritual gifts, and callings. He simply does not call everyone to live cookie cutter lives and, as David would argue, He seems to go out of His way to ensure that those who promote cookie cutter Christian living are not successful in the long term. (That is another post.)

Very early on in our marriage, we decided that although we did not feel we were ready to have children, we wanted to be open to whatever plan God might have for us. So we gave God every opportunity to give us children earlier than we would probably have chosen to have them. And if you asked us, we would have also told you that we wanted probably two or three. MAYBE four on a good day. But we have always thought that given our temperaments and personalities that we would do best with just a couple of children. However, we also wanted to be open to whatever God might have for us that we might not be able to fully comprehend at that point.

Well, if you’ve been reading this blog for any amount of time you know that all our “openness” resulted in zilch, zero, nada children (until this year). God simply had a different plan for us. And just because we have one on the way, it doesn’t mean that there will be any more. This could be the only child we have. God may send another one. He may send two more. Is it possible that our intuition about what was best was right all along? I certainly do not regret the choice we made to be open to whatever God might do, but I do find it really interesting that given our ages it seems likely that our conviction that “less is more” and “later would be better than sooner” for us when it comes to children seems to be playing out in the way God is ordering our lives.

Going back to Amy’s quote, I also think that sometimes less is more because perhaps God DOES need us to do Latin and Greek with our child. Maybe this baby I am carrying is going to grow up and become a brilliant theologian who will light a fire like Jonathan Edwards. (Hey, a mom can dream, right?) Maybe our one child will need the focused attention of his mother and father in order to fulfill that calling that God has for him in the Kingdom. Could God raise up a great theologian in a house with ten children? Of course! But just because He can, doesn’t mean that He will. It could be His plan to raise up our child without siblings. And it could be that we will never know the why of His plan until heaven. But if God only gives us one child, there is a reason for it.

It could also be that God only has one child for us because He has other things He needs David and me to do in the Kingdom and raising more children would interfere with those other plans.

As was addressed at the beginning of this entry, NO ONE CAN DO IT ALL. Is raising godly children a powerful part of the Kingdom? Of course! Is blogging to encourage other Christians a powerful part of the Kingdom? It can be if it is what God has called me to do and I do it faithfully. Is blogging or writing articles to challenge/encourage others in their Christian walk as important as raising a child for Christ? YES, if it is what God has called me to do in His Kingdom.

I am sure there are Christians who would vehemently disagree with me and say that raising as many children as you can for Christ is the “highest calling” for a Christian. I disagree. The highest calling for a Christian is doing exactly what God calls YOU to do based on the unique life situation, spiritual gifts, and temperament He has blessed you with.

For some believers that will include raising many children. For some believers, it will mean not raising ANY children. For some believers it means spending an hour or more in prayer daily. For others it means caring for an elderly relative. For other believers is means being single when they would rather be married. For some believers it means being an ethical business person.

The highest calling is being faithful and doing our best with whatever God has given us to do as His Kingdom representatives.

So those who would seek to impose their “absolutely biblical Christian living blueprint” on all believers should be careful to make sure that they are not seeking to usurp the role of the Holy Spirit in the life of believers around them and excessively burdening their brothers and sisters in Christ with expectations that are not of God.

There are those who are zealous for the things of God to the point where they are unwilling to allow God to lead His children as He sees fit. It is almost as though they are convinced THEY are the Holy Spirit that people need. What a terrible day it will be for them when the discover that in their zeal to make sure everyone was doing everything “right”, they caused others to miss out on the unique blessings and callings God had for them in the Kingdom. How many gifts to the body of Christ have been lost because brothers and sisters in Christ labored under expectations and beliefs that God never intended them to carry?

May each of us go forward today in that delicate and critical balance of grace and truth.

Category: Simple Living

About Sallie Borrink

Sallie Schaaf Borrink is a Christian, wife, mother, homeschooler, homebody, and autodidact. She owns a home-based graphic design and web design business with her husband (DavidandSallie.com).

You Might Also Like

Brighten the Corner Where You Are

Making Life Adjustments & Simple Living

Already Living My Grandmacore Life

Previous Post:My Pregnancy So Far (Because My Life Consists of Nothing Else Right Now!)
Next Post:“Pride and Prejudice” (2005) Review

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jeana

    Sunday, March 5, 2006 at 2:36 pm

    Amen, Sallie! It was funny, I blogged on this topic the same day Amy did. I guess a lot of us have been thinking about it!

    Reply
  2. Karen

    Sunday, March 5, 2006 at 5:54 pm

    Good thoughts, Sallie.

    My daughter and I were talking about this just the other day. We both enjoy reading and doing messy projects. So there is a trade-off and other things are neglected.

    I also think that we each do different things during different seasons of life. For example, when I still had 6 children at home and money was very tight,especially when keeping up with the appetites of 5 boys, I baked three loaves of bread every single day, just to be sure they were kept full with nutritional food. It is different now that I have less kids at home and I spend my time differently.

    Reply
  3. Bonnie

    Sunday, March 5, 2006 at 8:41 pm

    Sallie, I am so thankful you wrote this. You have thrown us bones about “living biblically” and your experiences in posts like the one on “systems,” but you have left me needing/wanting more of all the wisdom I know you’ve gained through these experiences. My husband and I are on a journey, as we all are, to live a biblical life, and sometimes it gets so convoluted with so many different “truths.” People can make anything sound right and good and true, and it is a worthy reminder to use our God given discernment when we are approached with all these different ideas.
    Excellent post. Thank you , again.

    Reply
  4. Anita

    Sunday, March 5, 2006 at 10:15 pm

    Thank you for this post!

    The highest calling for a Christian is doing exactly what God calls YOU to do based on the unique life situation, spiritual gifts and temperment He has blessed you with.

    This so needs to be said and resaid. I don’t know how it all gets so diverted so often, but I thank you for setting it straight.

    Reply
  5. Kristy

    Sunday, March 5, 2006 at 11:09 pm

    Thanks for this post–I needed it today. I agree with you but sometimes…it can be so easy to get side-tracked…

    Reply
  6. Cheri

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 5:11 am

    Good for you, Sallie. That was beautifully worded and right on.

    Right now I don’t do a single thing on your list, not even blog, but I have no doubt that I am following God’s will for my life and am taking good care of my family and the ministries that HE has given me. I am going to try to grow some flowers on my window sill this year if I don’t kill them as soon as they germinate.

    I am especially thankful that you and your husband were able to show that leaving God in charge of your life (as regarding children) didn’t mean you ended up with a dozen kids preventing everything else. Too many people think if they leave their life up to God’s will He will ruin everything for them. God isn’t the big Spoilsport in the Sky, He is an allwise, allcaring, allpowerful God who can be trusted!

    BTW I thought you were hoping for a girl!? 😉

    Reply
  7. Amie

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 7:41 am

    Good stuff, this was also what the sermon at church was about yesterday. He took it even a step further to say that when we have these ideas of being a REAL Christian is we build “filters” in our life that keep out people, sometimes the very people that need Christ in their life most. It was a very convicting. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

    And, I am hoping that you are feeling well 🙂

    Reply
  8. Lindsey

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 9:23 am

    Thank you Sallie! Very good stuff to ponder. I liked your quote about the “blueprint christian”…..

    Hope you’re feeling well…

    Reply
  9. Susanna Berry

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 9:29 am

    I love reading bogs, especially of Christian women in the USA, but for a while they actually had the opposite effect on me than their writers would have hoped. I sometimes felt an absolute failure that I was not home maker/ mother of many/ resourceful woman/ able to comment on things spiritualy etc. Now, some of this is down to me I know. But your blog sums up what the Lord has lead me to realise. I thank everyone who shares for their example, their wisdom, and walking the way God is leading them…..and now I will walk the way that God is leading me. I think I am Sallie like in outlook….

    Reply
  10. Sherri W

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 1:45 pm

    AMEN!!! I second, third, fourth, and fifth your motion!! You have completely encapsulated my frustration with the spiritualized version of “my way or the highway” mentality set forth by many. It seems that people who are rushing around- mentally, if not physically- to dress a certain way, school a certain way, cook/bake a certain way, etc. are often doing it because they feel “others” led instead of being led by the Spirit.

    Reply
  11. Crystal

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 11:32 pm

    I wrote a post with an almost identical title a few months back. 🙂

    By the way, congratulations on your pregnancy!! What exciting times you have ahead of you!!

    Reply
  12. Crystal

    Monday, March 6, 2006 at 11:40 pm

    I just found the link here to the post I was referring to with a similar title and theme(meant to include it in my comment!): http://www.biblicalwomanhoodonline.com/2005/11/cookie-cutter-christians.html

    Reply
  13. Sallie

    Wednesday, March 8, 2006 at 8:48 pm

    Ladies,

    Thank you for your kind comments. I’m humbled and blessed that so many were encouraged by what I wrote.

    Bonnie – I’m sorry I’ve been throwing “bones”. I’ll try to add a little more meat to them. Sometimes it is hard to know how much to say. And sometimes there is stuff I REALLY want to write about but it would be inappropriate because of the identifiability of some of the other people involved. I opt for discretion and sometimes that probably makes things seem kind of “boney”!

    Blessings to all!
    Sallie

    Reply
  14. Jessica

    Wednesday, August 30, 2006 at 11:14 pm

    wow. My very first post on my own blog was about this very thing, even down to the examples of babies vs. barrenness and single vs. married. It’s amazing how God speaks to all of us at different times but HE DOES SPEAK!

    Reply
  15. Felicity

    Saturday, December 23, 2006 at 6:21 am

    Thank you for your wonderful post. I loved your mention that “The highest calling for a Christian is doing exactly what God calls YOU to do based on the unique life situation, spiritual gifts and temperment He has blessed you with.” As a single women I have stuggled with wanting to do it all and to plan my own future for God. However this was a fantastic reminder that God has given us each different tasks to do and we are to take one day at a time in his strength and serve God with the gifts he has given US.

    Reply
  16. Emily

    Thursday, April 26, 2007 at 6:48 am

    Such a fantasitc post Sallie! I really needed to be reminded of this. How often do we take our own personal convictions and try to make them into a mould that we believe everyone else should be formed into? We must be very careful about pushing these things above the guidance of the Holy Spirit. Thanks for writing this!

    In His care, Emily

    Reply
  17. christian

    Tuesday, January 4, 2011 at 9:22 am

    wonderful article,thanks

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Kristy Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Thank you for your comment. I read and appreciate each one even if I am unable to respond.

Sidebar

Sallie Schaaf Borrink

For 20+ years, I’ve been writing about following Jesus Christ and making choices based on what is true, beautiful, and eternal. Through purposeful living, self-employment, and homeschooling, our family has learned that freedom comes from a commitment to thoughtfully examine all of life and think for yourself. 

I hope you enjoy browsing my content and don't forget to check out my Shop!

Search

Categories

Access my Premium Content

Popular Today

  • Free Apples Graphing Activity SQUAREFree Apples Graphing Activity
  • Free Canada Map Printable SQUAREFree Canada Map Printable for Homeschoolers
  • 100 Classic Children's Picture Books SIMPLE100 Classic Children’s Picture Books
  • Fancy Nancy Party Post Pin SIMPLEA Fancy Nancy Birthday Party – Planning Ideas On A Budget
  • 100 Wholesome Books for Girls and Tweens SIMPLE100 Wholesome Books for Girls and Tweens
  • Switching from Kindle to Kobo SIMPLESwitching To Kobo Libra Colour From Kindle
  • Popular-Today-List-Avatar-SB-GIRL-80x80Pansies Counted Cross Stitch Kits
  • 180 day countdownFree School Year Countdown Calendar Printable
  • Free Printable Journal Pages - Creating Your Cozy Life Planner 2Free Printable Classic Journal Pages
  • Trees By Joyce Kilmer Printable SQUARE“Trees” by Joyce Kilmer | Printable Poem

Recent Comments

  • Sallie Borrink on Review of Devotional Biology from Compass Classroom
  • Charlene Charriez on Review of Devotional Biology from Compass Classroom
  • Peggy on Choosing a Simpler and More Analog Life
  • Sallie Borrink on Choosing a Simpler and More Analog Life
  • Peggy on Trigger Points & Anxiety
  • Sallie Borrink on Raising Gifted Children in the Christian Faith
  • Tania on Raising Gifted Children in the Christian Faith
  • Charlene on The College Women Who Just Wanted to Watch “Christy”
  • Merrilyn MCelderry on The Blessings of Making a Home
  • Sallie Borrink on Living Simply By Limiting Emotional Drainers

Popular Today In My Shop

  • 50 United States Maps plus DC Printables IMAGE50 Blank Printable U.S. State Maps (plus Washington, D.C.)
  • Garden Activity Pack 042923Garden Themed Pack – Printable Worksheets & Activities
  • Penguin Fun Fact CardsPenguin Fun Fact Cards | Printable Activity
  • Fun Fact Cards SAMPLERFree Fun Fact Cards Sampler | Printable Activity
  • First Thanksgiving Writing Prompts 052923First Thanksgiving Writing Prompts
  • Our Heroes By Phoebe Carey Printable“Our Heroes” by Phoebe Carey
  • Apple Writing Prompts and Papers 052923 2Apple Writing Prompts and Papers
  • Distraction-Free Print Handwriting Sight WordsPrint Handwriting Practice Worksheets – 100 Sight Words
  • Bumblebee Paper Roll Craft 040320 01Bumblebee Paper Roll Craft

My Thinking About Theology Website

What Can I Help You Find Today?

Home

About Sallie

Contact

Privacy Policy

Disclaimers & Disclosures

Premium Content

Subscribe

Make a Donation

Tags

My Printables Shop

My Account

Cart

Lost Password Help

Digital Products Terms of Use

Simple Living

Unit Studies & Learning Themes

Homeschooling

Free Printables

Copyright © 2005–2026 · A Quiet Simple Life · All Rights Reserved · Powered by Mai Theme

Scroll Up
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.