I freely admit that I was skeptical about the value of Minecraft. Part of that was my own inherent bias since I’ve never been inclined to play video games. But after reading more about it, we decided to load the Minecraft – Pocket Edition onto our Kindle to see if Caroline would enjoy it. (She was seven and a half at the time and is now almost eight and a half.) It was cheaper to spring for the Kindle version than the PC version so we started there. I really wasn’t sure if she would even like it.
Wow. Minecraft has rocked our world in many ways. I was not expecting our family’s experience with Minecraft would be such a powerful and positive one for Caroline.
How Our Family Uses Minecraft
Caroline uses the Minecraft – Pocket Edition
Caroline started out playing in Survival mode, died almost instantly, and decided that Creative mode was far better. She did not want to spend her time trying to stay alive. She wanted to build things and explore.
She spends 95% of her time in Creative mode (although she has started branching out a bit with David into the lowest level of Survival mode the past few weeks). We don’t connect to an outside network.
Caroline also spends quite a bit of time watching Minecraft videos on YouTube. Like many kids who play Minecraft, she thoroughly enjoys Stampy and learns so much simply by watching what he does and creates.
Self-Directed Learning with Minecraft
Perhaps most profound for Caroline is that playing Minecraft is empowering. She is a very right-brained child. She does not like to be taught and thrives best with self-directed learning. Minecraft is a perfect fit for her in this regard.
In a very short amount of time she was whizzing around Minecraft and figuring out what to do. It was very empowering for a creative girl who is a visual-spatial learner. (By contrast, just looking at Minecraft overwhelms me. It’s not how I’m naturally wired.) The opportunity to run with something engaging was fantastic for her personality and learning style.
Reading, Vocabulary and Conversation
Caroline loves it when we read to her which we do every day and have since she was six months old. But she isn’t inclined to pick up a book and read on her own yet. However, she will pour over and read Minecraft books
Between the game, the books, the Stampy videos and the detailed conversations she has with David about Minecraft, I am amazed at her vocabulary development. She has always been verbal (which I attribute to being homeschooled and with two highly-verbal parents all day). Minecraft has opened another level to her conversation abilities and vocabulary.
Minecraft and Character Building
David spends time playing Minecraft with her so he has his own perspective on what it has meant to Caroline. When I asked him about this, he immediately began listing various character traits that he sees being developed through their Minecraft time together. These include:
- Perseverance – Continuing to look for the materials she wants and needs to complete the tasks she wants to accomplish
- Collaborating – Working together to accomplish a task including sharing materials
- Compromise – Learning to negotiate and come to an agreement about how to do something
- Confidence – Teaching her daddy how to play Minecraft was a significant experience for her
- Risk-taking – Being willing to try new things, accept if it doesn’t work out, and try again
- Courage – Going back into Survival mode was a big step for a highly-sensitive child
So overall we can see many good things coming from the time Caroline spends on Minecraft.
Parenting Challenges with Minecraft
Okay, so what are the parenting challenges associated with Minecraft? Let’s be honest. They exist.
The game is highly-engaging bordering on addictive. Caroline would spend hours and hours every day playing it and watching Minecraft videos if we would let her. But it’s not good for her neck, it’s not good for her hands, and it’s not the only thing she should be doing with her time.
That said, I also remember when I was a child and I would spend literally hours every day reading. I would lay on the couch and read until I was sick to my stomach. So what’s the difference? I was an avid reader. Caroline’s an avid Minecrafter. I suppose you can throw in the debate about whether all that screen time is good for her versus my reading books and I think that is valid.
I don’t have a solid answer for how much time is too much. We do have to cut her off because she will rarely put it down to do something else. This is a question every family will have to answer for themselves. But we do let her do Minecraft a couple of hours every day and hope that we’re making the right choice.
We have not dealt with the violence issue because she hasn’t wanted to play in Survival mode in the highest levels. I really can’t give an opinion about that aspect of it. Given her sensitive nature, I would be very surprised if she ever headed into that direction with it. I think she’ll continue to spend her time building houses, cities, gardens, spawning animals, etc. If we come to that question, then we’ll have to deal with it. At this point, that isn’t on our radar.
Not Turning Minecraft Into School
One choice we have deliberately made is to not turn Minecraft into school. There are lots of articles and ideas online about how you can use Minecraft to teach math, etc. We’re not going in that direction.
Caroline enjoys Minecraft because it is self-directed and it’s something she’s really good at on her own. If we come in, take over, and dictate to her what she’s going to start doing with it… What does that tell her? I believe she is already learning a great deal by using it. I trust that she will continue to do so. She doesn’t need us taking the pure joy out of it just so we can accomplish something on our agenda. Because we’re relaxed homeschoolers, this is something I’m comfortable with in our relaxed learning experiences. While I believe in the value of teachable moments, I also believe in allowing my child to discover her own interests on her own without my interference. This is one area where we are practicing that.
So do I recommend Minecraft? Absolutely.
Does it have value? Yes, I think it does.
Does it open up some challenging questions of parental management? Yes.
Is it worth the trouble? When I see the joy on my child’s face after she has completed some challenging task on her own, I know it is.
Lorelai actually takes Minecraft classes. WE LOVE THEM. The curriculum is laid out for us, the projects are still self-directed, and we learn together (always a plus!). She also takes Doctor Who classes. We don’t do these as a regular part of our schooling, but as fun stuff here and there. Mostly, she plays Minecraft with her brother or her BFF (she has a laptop in his room and one in her own room). I love that he (age 27) plays with her.
My 11 year old nephew LOVES Minecraft. Just as your daughter, he spends countless hours on YouTube looking at different Minecraft videos. He loves to build and explore and plans on being a scientist one day. I love that the game is self-directed because it teaches him SO much at a young age. (Whether he realizes it or not) Being creative and building his items allows him to think critically and exercises his lovely right-brained skills.
This is such a great article! Thank you!! My daughter also LOVES Minecraft, and we have made similar decisions. This was confirmation that we are doing the right thing showing her to learn and grow in her creativity. She is thriving since she began playing and is always eager to show me her latest creation. I don’t understand the draw of it either, but she enjoys it and is learning, so that is enough for now. =:
I really enjoyed this post, Sallie! My daughter (age 9) and son (age 6) have been obsessed with Minecraft for over a year. They play primarily on the Xbox. We have family that lives 5 hours away and it’s been so much fun for my kids to be able to play Minecraft online with their cousins who they normally wouldn’t get to play with that often. I’ve been blown away by their creativity and how they’ve worked together to build entire worlds. And so funny that you mention Stampy! Boy, have we watched our share of those videos! LOL!
Oh. Em. Kindred Soul!
My Mini will be 8 in June and I feel like I could have written this blog post! Lol. She is in LOVE with Stampy and watches him tirelessly. She stays in Creative Mode and only really goes out of it to show a new person what happens when you do.
Mini has a creative side (I take credit for that!) but I have really seen it come alive with her Minecraft skills. The detail she puts into her town (is that what they call it??) amazes me. She has this keen eye for detail that I think, although I might be biased ;), is seriously impressive (me!). A friend of mine has a son that is into Minecraft too. We love showing each other pics of the cool and sometimes weird stuff our kiddos come up with.
Also, I agree about the vocabulary aspect of it. Mini is not very verbal. She’s not a mute, but she is painfully shy (unfortunately, that’s me too) and had a hard time expressing herself. When I hear her explain different things about her little town, I almost cry!
I love Minecraft. I highly recommend it to anyone who is on the fence with it!
It’s so fun reading about how Minecraft has been a fun tool in other families! it obviously strikes a chord with certain kids and gives them something they enjoy.
Stephanie – That’s neat that the cousins can play together!
I like it a lot!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
“One choice we have deliberately made is to not turn Minecraft into school.” ~ ~ ~ I love this! My son already spends so much time in Minecraft, we’d lose balance if he were to take Minecraft math or literature class, for example.